Love Parade Disaster: The Parade Is Over

Image for Love Parade Disaster: The Parade Is Over

ITMers observed in shock over the weekend the gruesome events at the 2010 Love Parade festival, in which a horrific stampede amongst the overflowing crowd ended in tragedy with 19 people being killed in the crush and hundreds more suffering serious injuries. That news only got worse late last night when news emerged that an Australian festivalgoer was among that number of punters killed in the crush as Love Parade turned into an instant nightmare.

What strikes us most about the terrible turn of events at Love Parade is that the 2010 event was the 21st anniversary of the festival. In years prior, Love Parade had established itself as one of the premier events of the European summer, even exporting the festival brand to other cities around the world including San Francisco and Santiago, and it annually attracted waves of punters with the free outdoor shows in a celebration of peace and unity through music. It’s incredible to think that 20 years of hard work and countless great experiences have turned sour in just one day when things lost control.

So what went wrong with Love Parade? Already much of the blame has been attributed to the promoters behind Love Parade for poor event planning which allowed for only one, badly mapped entrance – the tunnel wherein the punter-crush began – to the Love Parade venue, not to mention below-par security personnel.

“It seems the organisers didn’t plan the route,” an American reveler, Taggart Bowen-Gaddy, told the AFP. “The road was very narrow…There was no planning, no one knew what was going on.” Another Love Parade attendee, Patrick Guenter, also added that “although the festival was full, they kept letting people in” and that on the whole the festival’s “organisation was very bad”.

As well as German officials and even the motherflippin’ Pope weighing in on the Love Parade fallout, a particularly vocal detractor of the promoters has been the man who started the festival back in 1989 before moving on from the event.

“It is the fault of the organisers,” Dr Motte was quoted as saying by Germany’s The Local press, with the founder and DJ launching into an attack on the festival’s poor organisation. “It is just about making money; the organisers did not show the slightest feeling of responsibility for the people.”

Fresh reports have also emerged today stating that this year’s venue – at Love Parade’s brief new home in Duisburg, Germany – had just a 250,000 person capacity, far below the estimated 1.4 million people in attendance.

Following the storm against the festival’s organisers, Love Parade promoter Rainer Schaller, bore the brunt of the public outcry, offering his regrets to the punters affected by the tragedy and declaring that Love Parade was officially finished.

“The Love Parade has always been a cheerful and peaceful event but will be overshadowed in the future by the events of yesterday. Out of respect for the victims, families and friends, we will discontinue the festival,” ABC News quotes Schaller as saying. “The Love Parade is no more.”

The organisers have have also been criticised for allowing Love Parade to continue despite the casualties from the crush, which is perhaps unfair considering that pulling those DJs and artists scheduled to play might have evoked only more panic and chaos in the crowd. For their part, the Love Parade artists have expressed their grief at the events, with German native Boys Noize live-Tweeting his reactions from the festival.

“I feel very sorry for what happened at the Loveparade. This is truly sad :( I am NOT going to play,” Boys Noize began. “cause 15 people died and about 50-100 got hurt. knowing this i just cant go up there and play for the rest 500 000 people [sic].”

“I want to send my deepest condolences to the families and friends of the people who died today…I am really upset and sad about this,” Tiesto also offered on his Twitter account.

The horror at Love Parade comes shortly after the similarly disturbing events at Electric Daisy Carnival in Los Angeles last month, which saw hundreds treated by medical officials due to stampeding fence-jumpers and, even more distressingly, an underage girl die after a drug overdose.

Two big events turning ugly in such quick succession paints a particularly grim picture of dance music festivals on the global circuit and it is seemingly already impacting on upcoming events, so we have to wonder if and how the festival scene will react with the scrutiny of the world now upon it. If nothing else this should confirm that solid organisation and an emphasis on patron safety is paramount to any festival’s success. But we also wonder if there’s an element of crowd aggression – which many ITMers pointed out as growing on the Australian festival circuit in our feature, Are Festivals Still About The Music – that needs to be addressed as we push forward. But that is all discussion for the future. Right now the dance world can only reflect on a very dark hour for electronic music.

Photo credit: Associated Press

Social

Comments

www.inthemix.com.au arrow left
277396
beatfreakn

beatfreakn said on the 26th Jul, 2010

Just out of curiosity (and this is a general observation, not an attack at the writer). Why is it that the news always becomes worse when we find out there was an Australian killed or injured or something of the like? Never mind the 18 other people who lost their lives and all the others affected.

R.I.P to those who passed. How horrible.

i_have_ADD

i_have_ADD said on the 26th Jul, 2010

i guess it makes the whole thing hit closer to home? you're right, it doesn't make it any less tragic an occurrence... the whole thing is so messed up, i haven't been able to stop thinking about it since i woke up sunday morning and first read the news. in all my time working at inthemix i've never had to report on something quite this serious. so, so sad :(

RaVeR_SpIkE

RaVeR_SpIkE said on the 26th Jul, 2010

i knew it this would happen after a disaster like this happened.

clasek

clasek said on the 26th Jul, 2010

this is such a sad day for dance music, its bad enough that the stigma that surrounds festivals is one where ppl go to get off their face on drugs now added to that will be the idea that they're just dangerous in general. Plus to see what could be called the worlds premier dance event canceled for good is sad. R.I.P To those who have lost their lives

narcism

narcism said on the 26th Jul, 2010

Loveparade Berlin was amazing, taking it out of Berlin was the first mistake.

narcism

narcism said on the 26th Jul, 2010

Loveparade Berlin was amazing, taking it out of Berlin was the first mistake.

InTheForest

InTheForest said on the 26th Jul, 2010

*waits for the media here to start wanking on about unsafe festivals* which will then lead to rise in ticket prices for so called "extra safety measures* that is a fail

sad day, I've been to sensation, tiesto in concert and tiesto at disneyland, crowd is nothing compared to this, but its still huge, and still kinda scary sometimes.

beatfreakn

beatfreakn said on the 26th Jul, 2010

I apologise ADD, I am sure that you were in no way insinuating that it was more tragic due to the loss of an Australian. I agree with you, I was being a dick.

angy

angy said on the 26th Jul, 2010

Has there been any indication that crowd aggression was involved? I'm sure it was just people responding to a scary situation - I'm remembering the genuinely dangerous conditions that crowds were subjected to when Cypress Hill played at side stage at Good Vibrations a few years ago - I remembered at the time how quickly things could have gotten ugly. If you're going to have massive amounts of people in an enclosed space, you need to plan carefully.

meow_girrrl

meow_girrrl said on the 26th Jul, 2010

What a terrible month for music festivals :<

diva_demands

diva_demands said on the 27th Jul, 2010

this is so tragic, scary to think a mismanaged event can result in so many deaths

AndySan

AndySan said on the 27th Jul, 2010

What a tragedy! My heart goes out to people who were killed / injured and their families!

Angy, I was also there and I remember that well! I also remember the idiots who decided to climb the poles, and cypress hill had to keep stopping the show to tell the idiots to "get the F*** down!"

Better planning and organisation is needed to make sure these sort of things don't happen again!

erooonar

erooonar said on the 27th Jul, 2010

what a tragedy :(
I know might be a bit of a silly question, but was it a free festival or did punters have to purchase tickets?

i_have_ADD

i_have_ADD said on the 27th Jul, 2010

beafreakn> no offense taken, i will admit i usually share that view. a life lost is a life lost, no matter where they're from... but something about that poor australian girl has just really gotten to me - maybe it's having friends the same age who have been travelling, visiting events just like love parade. it really gets right to your core when you think it could have just as easily been someone you know. cannot imagine how her friends and family must be feeling, with it happening so far away from home.

Norbert

Norbert said on the 27th Jul, 2010

Makes me appreciate how well Defqon 1 in Penrith was run last year. Lots of people at the venue and a lot of room to move. Can't wait till Sept!!!!!!!!!!

djbricksta

djbricksta said on the 27th Jul, 2010

Festival organisers need to learn from this. People have mentioned overcrowding at festivals like the Big Day Out in past years and I hope they take note with greed vs safety and an enjoyable day

Ruskhouse

Ruskhouse said on the 27th Jul, 2010

yeah except defqon isnt a festival. its a congregation of the same sounding music and bunch of loser lad cunts

walkdogz

walkdogz said on the 27th Jul, 2010

I suspect it'll be back... eventually.

At least with a different name.

it's not like Germany is never going to have another massive outdoor mobile dance music festival ever again.

Time heals, things change, standards improve, and people move on.

Chemo

Chemo said on the 27th Jul, 2010

This is sooo sad... I studied in Berlin during the 90ies and the Love Parade back then had been such an amazing event, the commercialized rip-off festivals that we find here in Australia nowadays are nothing compared to it. However, the Love Parade belongs to Berlin like the Mardi Gras parade belongs to Sydney and moving it away from there killed it from the start. It was originally moved due to the complaints of nazi-like so-called 'environmentalists' who in reality were just old conservative fucks who couldn't stand some fun-loving young people making a bit of noise once a fu...ing year which was paired with absolutely incompetent city officials who didn't see the marketing value of having this internationally known youth festival in their city.

We always wondered how you could have this event happen at a different location, given that in Berlin it was held right in the center of a huge park which allowed the masses to buffer into the park lands around it. In order to understand what was happening now, imagine a huge dance festival with 1 plus Million visitors that was held, just for argument's sake, at the Domain in Sydney. And now they suddenly change the location to an old run-down factory area in, let's say Wollongong. Just imagine the train station there and you get an idea what was happening here...

The so-called "Love parade" that happened this weekend only shared the name with the original event and was nothing more than a commercial vehicle for a greedy gym-chain owner and the local council government of an ugly and extremely unattractive little town in the far west of Germany, an area similar to Northern England known mainly for its (dieing) heavy industry. It is therefore no wonder they wanted such a festival to happen there at all cost in order to polish their battered image a little bit and therefore ignored any warnings about safety. The latter actually DID get voiced prior to the event and the parade just a year before in a similar smaller town just next door actually had been cancelled due to safety concerns.

What makes me most angry is that the same kind of ultra-conservative old fucks that killed the real Love Parade in Berlin years ago, are now the ones that take this tragic event as a reason to condemn that "awful ounz ounz music" and young people in general. Fuck off, I say! X(

Sunrize

Sunrize said on the 28th Jul, 2010

OMG a festival of 1.4million people........thats just nuts

LaLLy

LaLLy said on the 28th Jul, 2010

It was nuts - it was an amazing festival! I have never experienced anything like it, and doubt I ever will again... The crowd were very placid, friendly, not wasted on drugs/alcohol, just there to be free and have a good time. It's so sad that it could end in the opposite that LP promotes.

Shame on terrible news reporters for demonising 'techno music fans' (The Age). This festival was in the best of interests and always has been, unlike Muzza-fests of speed in Oz! Oh why oh why do the best ones always get ruined...

I'm sorry I continued partying on the day (oblivious), but that's what those who died would've wanted everyone to do...

PEACE & LOVE

Tinax3

Tinax3 said on the 4th Aug, 2010

But its the LOVE parade! not so nice after all :(