Australian dance panel: The state of the scene

Image for Australian dance panel: The state of the scene

Last week, we published an excerpt from the Australian dance scene panel at the International Music Summit in Ibiza, which covered the changing fortunes of festivals here. Now, as a few of you requested, we’ve got the complete transcript of the 40 minute discussion, which touched on the state of Australian radio, the club climate, whether local artists need to seek international success, and more.

inthemix: My name’s Tim Duggan, I’m the Content Director for inthemix, which is Australia’s biggest dance music community. We have an esteemed panel today, so to start off we’ll get people to introduce themselves.

Jon Hanlon: My name is Jon Hanlon from Konkrete Agency, we’re a small, boutique domestic agency. We also represent Laidback Luke, Nicky Romero and a few others for the Australian territory. We work closely with Stereosonic, Onelove and others. I’m looking forward to this panel. It’s going to be extremely interesting.

Bev Malcolm: Hi, I’m Bev, I’m dance A&R for EMI Australia and also I work with Stereosonic. We’re the ‘all over the place’ people at this end of the panel.

Grant Smillie: I have Neon Records and a national radio program, agency and run a couple of clubs. I’ve worked with all these guys in a number of ways.

Kaz James: I’m Kaz James, a DJ/producer from Bodyrockers.

Richie McNeill: I’m from Stereosonic festival and Creamfields. We run a lot of tours with DJs like Armin van Buuren, Carl Cox and Paul van Dyk. 20 years in the business, and that’s that.

Wade Cawood: I’m Wade, I look after Pulseradio and Finely Tuned and I don’t work for Stereosonic.

Matt Nugent: I work for the Onelove record label doing A&R and licensing. We’re an independent label that started from a club night. It spawned a compilation series and we also have a joint venture with Sony Australia. I’m a DJ as well.

inthemix: Australia’s at a fascinating place in dance music at the moment. For a country of only 20 million people, it certainly punches over its weight. It’s the sixth largest music market in the world, and for the past few years, there’s been an over-saturation of festivals, which is surely of interest to the rest of the world. There’s been an adjustment over the year, where the strong ones have survived, and others haven’t. Richie, what’s your take on the health of the Australian festival market right now?

Richie McNeill, Stereosonic: There are a lot of festivals in Australia. Compared to other countries, we’ve had a strong festival climate over the last 20 years. I think it’s got a lot to do with the fact that our summer season is long – from October/November to March/April. I guess every Tom, Dick and Harry has come here from overseas to try to do festivals – some have succeeded, some haven’t. Australia’s probably very different from other countries because a lot of festivals overseas like Electric Daisy Carnival or Glastonbury are just one weekend.

Our festivals are more like a travelling circus – five festivals in two weekends. Competition is really healthy. We try to look at the end product and the individual punter who comes to the festival: how can we make it easy for them on the day? The ones who cut corners and do shitty production, or the line-up isn’t so strong, or the price is too much, won’t survive.

Comments

www.inthemix.com.au arrow left
305865
daverh

daverh said on the 6th Jun, 2012

I think we're pretty spoiled down here and it irks me to see people moaning about A-list DJs coming here frequently - as in once or twice each year. There's a limited pool of artists, and specifically headliners, to draw here yet the gripes still come. Because we're isolated from the northern hemisphere should tours be 'rare'?

mlirosi

mlirosi said on the 6th Jun, 2012

It appears dave has acquired a hammer and a nail, and used the hammer to hit the nail directly on the head. anywhere else in the world you would have internationals with residency at a club and can see them once a week i cant understand how everyone will complain about seeing an artist twice or three times a year

haynesyy

haynesyy said on the 6th Jun, 2012

I agree with you mlirosi. Although I think the biggest issue is set selection. Take Armin for example, I've seen him play a club set here, Armin Only and his Summerfieldayze Stereosonic stints. SFD and Stereo both the sets were just his tracks promoting Mirage, while the club set back in 09 was more like an A State of Trance episode with a bunch of good tunes mixed with his hits to get everyone excited. So that's where overseas seeing a DJ every week is about good music and having fun, whereas festivals here involve a lot more of that DJ's hits and not a great deal of creativity. Probably the reason why punters complain about seeing the same thing twice.

mlirosi

mlirosi said on the 6th Jun, 2012

yer i can agree with that, just take stereo 2011, dirty south, kaskade and carl coz had all released albums within months of them touring and they use festivals such as the 'stereo circuit' as a promotional weapon

jimmenyC

jimmenyC said on the 7th Jun, 2012

Was this article focused on the state of the 'scene' or festival scene specifically....

khas

khas said on the 7th Jun, 2012

'The kids are getting savvier, and they don%u2019t want to see the same acts every time.'

As I interpreted; 'we can't keep shoveling them the same shit like we used to'

ALL_CAPS

ALL_CAPS said on the 9th Jun, 2012

Firstly, interesting panel composition. Cawood and James should not be there, end of story.

Secondly, insightful observations from Nugent.

Bev claims his competition is nothing like Next Top Model yet the promo is EXACTLY like it.

Kaz James doesn't trouble the scorers, much like his career these days.

Wade Cawood arrived in Sydney 6 years ago and according to him there was nothing beforehand and no one promoted anything decent. Nowadays Sydney has got slightly better, according to Cawood, and has one half-decent venue. He neglects to mention he's banned from using most other venues in Sydney. He really fails to mention anything beyond Sydney, in fact anything beyond himself - proving neatly why he should never have been on the panel.

Richie Rich explains courteously and almost apologetically to Cawood why he can't enter into a collusive price-fixing arrangement with Future Entertainment.

Oh the lols. As Crackers said, they talk a good game but nothing is really changing. As long as they get the kids' money right?

rubbishtalk

rubbishtalk said on the 11th Jun, 2012

Interesting read!
The main reason why there aren't any great clubs in Sydney is because the rent is so expensive and the liquor licensing laws screw you. I had a friend try to start a club and he said it just was not financially viable whereas places like Berlin have super cheap rent which allows creativity to flourish...

laurenx

laurenx said on the 12th Jun, 2012

There's a few times in this article when Wade sounds like he's frustrated, possibly because the other guys weren't really listening. It's true what he's saying about clubs, but no one really offered any solutions. This is why the scene has shifted to more warehouse/underground/interesting spaces. I don't remember the last time I went to a club. Promoters/club owners need to give us a good reason to get back to clubs. Until then I'm quite happy partying in warehouses where you can take your own drinks, security is chilled and the people are there for the music.

rolf harris

rolf harris said on the 14th Jun, 2012

there is no scene in Australia, well if you call a scene a hand full of clubs in Melbourne,Sydney, Perth and Brisbane playing quality music whilst the rest play top 40 garbage and over priced,crowded festivals in summer a scene then yay.

Weinertron

Weinertron said on the 15th Jun, 2012

Good point laurenx. I haven't been attracted to the idea of going to the club for aages. Clubs are highly regulated these days when compared with going to a club maybe 8-10 years ago (I'm talking about Melbourne here). Going to a warehouse or private function or party in the park or even going bush (doofs!) is a great deal more attractive than heading to the club, not only because of the ability to bring your own drinks but interesting spaces breed creativity and can create a unique vibe.

Whilst I have had some amazing club experiences, after a few years the format did get a bit stale for me and I'm guessing that many punters felt the same - it's no accident that we've had a festival explosion... the market demanded it! When I think of the first few "festivals" I went to (Good Vibes, Parklife, etc) they were excellent because finally here were all my favourite artists in one spot! But, like any other aspect of music, the format is subject to fads and crazes and EDM fans simply got sick of festivals en masse. (the kids still seem to love em though).

In short, I'm not sure where the future of EDM in Australia is headed, but I think festivals are not the answer. And if clubland wants to make a return to people's hearts, they are going to need to make the format new and exciting. I'm not sure how they will manage it, particularly with the financial restrictions (maybe focus on the locals? I dunno) but it needs to be done. Boom. New format. There you go, I solved the problem.

NB: everyone talks about festivals as being a recent thing, but what about all that other stuff people used to go to? Two Tribes, Hardware Universe (@ Kryal), Sunshine People and other nighttime "festivals". Have people forgotten about these? do they not count as "festivals?" why/why not? Maybe a return to night festivals is long overdue....

LHolland

LHolland said on the 17th Jun, 2012

This discussion was far too short.

Suspekt

Suspekt said on the 25th Jun, 2012

Would have been nice to include a few panel members not involved with massive major festivals and touring brands... surely that doesn't represent Australia's dance scene to the fullest?