inthemix Forums
Page 1 of 2

inthemix Forums (http://www.inthemix.com.au/forum/index.php)
-   Gaming, Computers, Phones, and Gadgets (http://www.inthemix.com.au/forum/forumdisplay.php?f=19)
-   -   What internets should I get? (http://www.inthemix.com.au/forum/showthread.php?t=192969)

MadMike 18-Mar-07 11:57pm

Search for plans that suit your needs - http://bc.whirlpool.net.au/bc/?action=search

Opinion on what is good/bad - http://forums.whirlpool.net.au/

FAQ on Choosing a broadbrand provider - http://whirlpool.net.au/wiki/?tag=Ch...Provider%20FAQ

Australian Bureau of Statistics - Internet Activity - June 2014
http://www.abs.gov.au/ausstats/abs@.nsf/mf/8153.0/

Gruso 01-Dec-14 09:17am

After seven years of sitting here locked in beta, I think we'll open this thread for general discussion of home & mobile internet connections. Because sometimes it's nice to supplement your research with advice from Good Pals.

Please use this thread for:
  • Seeking advice on internet plans, after you've looked at Broadband Choice. We do advice; not homework.
  • Posting your jerk speedtest results

Please don't use the thread for general tech help or industry news. Suggested threads for these topics:

ChemicalJames 05-Dec-14 07:41pm

Slightly off topic:
Does anyone know who's providing the biggest mobile phone data plan for under $100 a month? I'm currently paying Telstra $80 for 2.5gig but Otus has 8gig plans for $100 and i'd get a free new phone.

I guess the other question is are the non-telstra/optus as bad as i think they are? I travel around regional victroia for work so reception is vital

Dr Rudi 06-Dec-14 12:05am

Are the locations you're visiting in regional Victoria often the same?

http://cellsite.nudge.id.au/

^check proximity to the towers at the addresses you frequent most on the above map, go with provider that has highest ratio of close towers to places you often visit.

hint: 90% chance it'll be Telstra

The other helpful thing would be to get a 3G modem with an external antenna connector and get a high gain antenna - just for emergencies where the inbuilt antenna is struggling.

ChemicalJames 06-Dec-14 05:27am

Nah the places i visit aren't the same. I've been told optus are pretty good these days. I can handle a few more reception deadzones if it means i get 5 gig extra data.

Gruso 07-Dec-14 09:42am

Is there a definitive Broadband Choice type site for mobile plans? Found these, but haven't looked in depth:

http://youcompare.com.au/mobilephones

http://www.plancrunch.com.au

http://www.phonechoice.com.au/

Derelict 07-Dec-14 10:13am

Quote:

Originally Posted by ChemicalJames (Post 395508706)
Nah the places i visit aren't the same. I've been told optus are pretty good these days. I can handle a few more reception deadzones if it means i get 5 gig extra data.

Optus are fine, mostly. I worked all over Victoria the past two years and I only had a couple of black spots in some really remote, rural areas outside of Bendigo. Usually had H connection everywhere I went.

Funny story though, when I moved to Brisbane I had no reception at my house. Turns out I'm in a known Optus black spot. So they sent me a digital receiver/booster that plugs into the network. I think they've since fixed the black spot, but I'm still running the thing anyway.

ABitPatchy 11-Dec-14 02:12pm

Anyone here with SkyMesh for NBN?

Just signed up with them after doing some whingepool research.

2TB 100/40 for $79 a month. No lock in contract and an Australian call Centre.

Mickstah 11-Dec-14 02:21pm

Damn that's pretty good.

I'm with Internode, 300GB 50/20 $85 per month. The beautiful thing about FTTP is you actually get those speeds.

nrjize 11-Dec-14 02:35pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by ABitPatchy (Post 395509760)
Anyone here with SkyMesh for NBN?

Just signed up with them after doing some whingepool research.

2TB 100/40 for $79 a month. No lock in contract and an Australian call Centre.

HNNNG! That sounds very, very satisfying.

NismoR31 11-Dec-14 03:58pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by ABitPatchy (Post 395509760)
Anyone here with SkyMesh for NBN?

Just signed up with them after doing some whingepool research.

2TB 100/40 for $79 a month. No lock in contract and an Australian call Centre.

i'm trying to work out why on earth they wouldn't list their plans & prices on their website. Only for the ISTAR satellite shit

good thing whingepool has it all http://bc.whirlpool.net.au/bc/isp-75...-nbn-fibre.htm


they sound very tpg-ish oversubscription model but being fibre connected nbn would it really matter?

ABitPatchy 11-Dec-14 04:10pm

They match any other provider deals as well. Showed them the DODO plans and that's what they came back with.

Congestion wise they are getting great reviews so who knows. If they're shit I can drop them after a month anyway.

I may never leave the house again.

big eddie 11-Dec-14 04:12pm

It matters more. You get your advertised circuit to the NBN/carrier POI. Beyond that you are at the mercy of your providers upstream bandwidth and traffic management.

Gruso 10-Feb-15 05:15pm



Glad to be up and running (well, glad for the old man to be up and running). But never use Spintel.

It was connected Monday last week, but we couldn't get the net working. Three days later they sent a text saying the phone was cut over. The phone was still dead on both copper & fibre, but the ADSL was still operating, so we decided to leave it for the weekend and see what happened. Come Monday (yesterday), phone still dead and ADSL down too.

Calls to after hours support were met with the old favourite "high volume of calls", followed by "call back later". Every night. So the old man finally got on the blower today, and after a full hour on hold was told that he merely needed the correct PPPoE login details, which the tech gave to him. This somewhat critical information was never communicated - no emails, no texts, no letters. No help on their site, no WP rep present in the past 3 months.

With the internet sorted, they turned to the phone issue. For some reason Spin has you connecting your phone to their provided D-Link modem, instead of the NTD as all the advice seems to suggest. And even after the guy attempted to configure it through Teamviewer, it's still dead.

A+

[edit] So it's not uncommon to use the modem's VOIP port instead of the NTD's Uni-V. Anyway, service not registering, will let the old man battle it out with them in his ample free time.

Gruso 01-Aug-15 11:15am

Spintel NBN, 9pm vs 1am.




NismoR31 01-Aug-15 11:32am

lole we don't oversubscribe, honest john.

Gruso 03-Aug-15 08:10pm

Fuck me, is this real life?


NismoR31 04-Aug-15 10:36am

shoulda internode.

big eddie 04-Aug-15 10:37am

I am Jack's complete lack of surprise.

Gruso 01-Sep-15 08:04am

Resposting from chat thread:

Quote:

Originally Posted by Gruso (Post 395555130)
Spintel verdict:

Quote:

1. Internet speed issue is caused by congestion in our wholesaler's network (Optus) with an estimated time of repair on April 2016.
2. You opted to leave SpinTel without any termination Fee or 30 days notice.
April 2016. Those poor, clueless souls who will be dealing with this until then. Despite the free pass I'm tempted to contact the TIO anyway. What a shit operation.

So I started shopping around again last night, which mostly involved a few hours reading Whirlpool. It seems like this issue isn't limited to shitcan providers like Spintel. Massive bandwidth demands (Netflix) and high CVC costs mean that almost all providers are susceptible to the problem. Especially the resellers, and that's most of them.

Remember the dozens of small time mobile phone providers running on resold, choked up Optus bandwidth? They're back, in NBN form.

I'm trying to scrape together a list of providers that buy direct from NBNco. It's looking to be a pretty short list that includes Telstra and Skymesh among others. The latter seems to be universally praised (so much so that I started to wonder if it was a military grade astroturfing operation). I'm thinking they're worth a shot though, and there's no lock-in.

Here's a really interesting blog post from back in July, explaining how the current CVC model isn't sustainable. It's short and digestible so I won't tl;dr it:

http://blog.jxeeno.com/cvc-remains-t...threat-to-nbn/

Rocca 01-Sep-15 09:40pm


Gruso 03-Sep-15 08:01pm

Learnings. There are hardly any providers who use their own backhaul. These ones do, and for me at least, this makes it the shortlist for ISP shopping:
  • Aussie Broadband
  • iiNET/Internode
  • Optus
  • SkyMesh
  • Telstra
  • TPG

Some others have their own backhaul from limited POIs, but resell in other areas. These include:
  • Harbour ISP
  • Activ8me

The other three squillion popup providers are Crazy Johns and should probably be avoided. Disclaimers: List is based on WP advice and may not be complete or accurate. Also, going with a provider that has their own infrastructure is no guarantee that there won't be congestion issues.

Anyway, the old man is going to give Skymesh a crack.

NismoR31 03-Sep-15 08:28pm

ie, should've gone with internode.

Gruso 03-Sep-15 08:56pm

Even the hallowed 'node is susceptible to congestion: http://advisories.internode.on.net/

At least they communicate though.

plan-b 07-Sep-15 11:09pm

Since TPG are now our iiNet/Internode overloards what's the current state of play on here? I'm looking at jumping to TPG since that's where I'm likely to end up there anyway, and their unlimited Naked ADSL2+ plan is $10 less than what I'm paying for 600GB a month with iiNet. Transparent proxies are supposedly no longer an issue, and the estimates on their coverage map are pretty comparable to my iiNet speeds. No cable and NBN isn't even planned in my area, so I've got a whopping choice of ADSL2+ and ADSL2+ for internet.

Gruso 08-Sep-15 07:37am

iiNet is still an independent operation* so don't expect to get the same level of service if you jump to TPG. If iiNet is working fine for you (no issues with peak time congestion etc) I would suggest staying put, because you don't know what you're going to get if you jump ship.

Also weigh up TPG's "unlimited" vs iiNet's quota free content. I get by on a 150GB Internode plan, because things like Netflix and Steam are unmetered.

See if you can find people in your area on WP. They might have advice on which ISPs are better on your exchange.

*mostly
*for now

plan-b 08-Sep-15 08:05pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by Gruso (Post 395555907)
iiNet is still an independent operation* so don't expect to get the same level of service if you jump to TPG. If iiNet is working fine for you (no issues with peak time congestion etc) I would suggest staying put, because you don't know what you're going to get if you jump ship.

The takeover's well and truly underway and strings are well and truly being pulled. iiNet's replacement CEO for Michael Malone was let go about a week ago, so was Internode's key PR guy (two key guys responsible for their customer service reputation) and there's already talks of major board restructures. iiNet service levels have reportedly dropped as well.

And I am suffering issues with peak time congestion (since around the time Netflix launched).

Quote:

Also weigh up TPG's "unlimited" vs iiNet's quota free content. I get by on a 150GB Internode plan, because things like Netflix and Steam are unmetered.
Way ahead of you, I used to buy a lot of music from the iTunes Music Store which is unmetered on iiNet. Now that I stream it instead from Apple Music, it's now metered (as well as moving a few other things to cloud storage). I've already had to bump my plan up as a result (which is how this started)

Quote:

See if you can find people in your area on WP. They might have advice on which ISPs are better on your exchange.
Ugh, I hate that place.

Quote:

*mostly
*for now
I think it'll happen sooner than you think.

I will likely stay put for the time being. It's a lot of hassle to change and means recontracting. Also, when it came to Telstra wholesale, iiNet were down the bottom of the pile, but they knew it and they did try to make up for it in other ways.

Gruso 08-Sep-15 08:31pm

Yeah, the whole country is being screwed by Netflix demand at the moment. Even NBN - see my FTTP speed tests up the page.

Anyway you're clearly well informed on the TPG debacle so I'm not sure what advice you need. Personally I wouldn't touch TPG with a barge pole. But the results will vary by exchange and that's why you have to brave Whirlpool. There's a massive national userbase, so you're likely to find feedback from someone in your area. That's the most reliable indicator you'll get.

Mickstah 08-Sep-15 08:31pm

As long as “that news thing” stays active I'm happy.


Edit: News is best lefts unsaid…

Gruso 08-Sep-15 08:34pm

Love me some news.

plan-b 08-Sep-15 08:45pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by Gruso (Post 395556064)
Personally I wouldn't touch TPG with a barge pole.

Pretty much this. It's a sad state of affairs for us DSL plebs :(

Gruso 10-Sep-15 08:26pm

So. Skymesh. The old man put the application in this morning. By this evening he had instructions to plug into the Uni-D 2 port, and that was that.


Mickstah 10-Sep-15 10:02pm

But how are the speeeds?!

plan-b 22-Sep-15 07:29pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by plan-b (Post 395556055)
will likely stay put for the time being. It's a lot of hassle to change and means recontracting. Also, when it came to Telstra wholesale, iiNet were down the bottom of the pile, but they knew it and they did try to make up for it in other ways.

Sorted, all iiNet Naked DSL plans are now 1TB no peak/off peak. Support lady bumped me down to their lowest plan which is the same price as TPG's unlimited plan (no included VoIP calls, which I never use anyway) and waived the $30 downgrade fee. Happy daze :thumb:

NismoR31 23-Sep-15 07:39am

iinet plans are sounding a lot like TPG ads. Read them in that chick's voice

http://www.iinet.net.au/internet/broadband/naked-dsl/

Dr Rudi 23-Sep-15 11:30am

And it has begun.

nrjize 11-Oct-15 05:45pm

Ditched iiNet after 12 years on Saturday. Signed up for Bigpond cable with the speedboost. Looking forward to 100mbit!

Tough call to leave iiNet and move to Telstra but our sync speeds on ADSL are dismal in this new house and Telstra data inclusions / prices are competitive.

Will post speedtest results to see how close the real world speeds are to the theoretical max once we're connected.

Mickstah 12-Oct-15 10:47am

How much are you paying for that?
What upload speeds do they promise?

NismoR31 12-Oct-15 11:00am

Bigpong cable plans on 24 month contract:
(can do month to month but cost is higher/month)

25Mb down / 1 up

100GB $75/mo
500GB $95/mo
1TB $115/mo

Speed boost is an extra $20/mo for 100 down / 2 up

Dr Rudi 12-Oct-15 11:42am

Actually Nis, normal is 32mb down/1mb up, speedboost of course 100mb down/2mb up - but speed boost is more like 115mb down if not in a congested cable area.

Jize - Probs wise to hang onto your adsl until cable is actually connected, shit does sometimes go very wrong with cable installations - went through a whole stuck in captive portal buttfuck for weeks when I tried to get a new modem set up a while back, hopefully they've fixed that issue by now though.

NismoR31 12-Oct-15 12:10pm

Are you arguing with their website? Coz it says 25/1.

Dr Rudi 12-Oct-15 12:34pm

Back when I originally signed up at my previous place and at my current place it was sold as 32mb. Generally hit between 34-36mb.

That kinda sucks if they've downgraded.

big eddie 12-Oct-15 12:38pm

iI will still sync @ 32 - they are attempting to sanitise the marketing material between adsl/cable/NBN. NBN doesn't offer 32meg circuits but does to 25. so the extra 7 megabits is the consumer surplus.

Dr Rudi 12-Oct-15 12:49pm

After a bit of reading, ~32mb was the max "boost" speed on docsis2 hardware, so yeah, they might have changed the speeds on docsis3 plans to align with the NBN.

Derelict 12-Oct-15 12:55pm

Why is Internet so expensive in this country?

Although my NBN deal isn't bad, 100Mbit/40Mbit 500gb/500gb peak/off peak for $100. I think it's $60 for 40/10 and 100/100.

Dr Rudi 12-Oct-15 01:19pm

Well, mostly because they didn't have the smarts to roll out the NBN to profitable higher density areas early on, and instead focussed mostly on bumfuck nowhere regional areas.

big eddie 12-Oct-15 01:40pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by Dr Rudi (Post 395559810)
Well, mostly because they didn't have the smarts to roll out the NBN to profitable higher density areas early on, and instead focussed mostly on bumfuck nowhere regional areas.

Because they definitely use the same contractors for regional areas as inner urban ones...

nrjize 12-Oct-15 02:33pm

Yeah we're leaving the ADSL connected until everything is sweet. Given I work from home full time and a lot of that is spent on social media / online I can't afford to have any internet downtime.

Dunno the final price as the other half went in store to negotiate but he's got a Telstra mobile and the housemate pays for the Foxtel separately so we've bundled it all under 1 account for a good discount compared to what everyone was paying individually.

Voluntarily signing up for a Telstra bundle. There's something I never thought I'd do in my life...

Dr Rudi 12-Oct-15 03:27pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by big eddie (Post 395559811)
Because they definitely use the same contractors for regional areas as inner urban ones...

Did they not focus on regional areas and avoid metro when they first started the NBN? Because the rollout in Sydney metro has been very pissweak.

The whole socialist agenda subsidising regional bumfucks who made a lifestyle choice by living away from the greater population is pretty darn wasteful imo. These people should simply have sold their homes and moved closer to exchanges :whyioughtta:

NismoR31 12-Oct-15 03:38pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by Dr Rudi (Post 395559829)
The whole socialist agenda subsidising regional bumfucks who made a lifestyle choice by living away from the greater population is pretty darn wasteful imo. These people should simply have sold their homes and moved closer to exchanges :whyioughtta:

How many farms can you fit next to your big city exchange?


All times are GMT +10. The time now is 05:57am.
Page 1 of 2

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.6.12
Copyright ©2000 - 2018, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
© 1999-2011, inthemix dot com dot au Pty Ltd