OPTIONS :

UK chief drugs advisor sacked for "telling the truth"


Hey, thanks for visiting the inthemix forums! Seeing as you're not logged in, you're probably new around here. You're welcome to browse around but if you really want to get the most out of the forums, you'll want to get involved and that means posting! Becoming a member is free and gives you access to post new and respond to existing threads, send private messages (PM) to other members, respond to polls and access other member-only features. So what are you waiting for? It doesn't take very long, so register now.

 

Reply
 
Thread Tools Search this Thread
Old 02-Nov-09, 02:25pm   #1
dbb618
Mortal Avatar
 
dbb618's Avatar
 
Member Since: May 2006

MemberID: 89387
Location: Bubble Metropolis
Posts: 9,129
UK chief drugs advisor sacked for "telling the truth"

http://www.abc.net.au/news/stories/2...02/2730355.htm

And this is why the game will never stop.


A row has broken out in Britain, after the chief drugs adviser to the government was sacked when he said alcohol and cigarettes were more dangerous than cannabis.

Other scientists on the drugs advisory council have resigned in protest, complaining the government is ignoring science in favour of popular myths.

When Professor David Nutt made his statements on marijuana, he thought he was simply telling the truth.

He said the drug was reclassified from class C to the more dangerous category B against scientific evidence, simply on the whim of Prime Minister Gordon Brown.

The reaction from the government was swift and unforgiving. Home Secretary Alan Johnson sacked him by email.
...
Professor Nutt is not going quietly. He insists his views are supported by science and experts in the field, while the government is guided by populist misinformation.

"This government is the first government that has gone against our recommendations," he said.

"It has done it on cannabis. It has done it on ecstasy and to be honest, if it had even asked us, it would have done it against mushrooms but it didn't even have the courtesy to ask us about mushrooms.

"So this government has made the law and then it has gone back to the advisory council and said 'could you find some evidence to support our decision?'

"Now we've said 'no, we will stick to science, our scientific guns, we will produce the evidence and if you go and legislate inappropriately, we will continue to point out the evidence does not support you'."
__________________
http://www.last.fm/user/dbbrx8/tracks

http://twitter.com/derekbradley

Quote:
Originally Posted by B_e_de
ur fkn drubnk
its the drunjunation of the future
dbb618 is online now   Reply With Quote
Old 02-Nov-09, 02:30pm   #2
CheelWinston
Chalkface
 
CheelWinston's Avatar
 
Member Since: May 2001

MemberID: 1134
Location: Cellz
Posts: 7,151


'recent research shows it's not so darn harmful'
__________________
cheel (till the next episode)

"Don't playa hate, calculate!"
"Don't playa hate, navigate!"
"Don't playa hate, amputate!"
"Don't playa hate, self-mutilate!"
"Don't playa hate, masticate!"
CheelWinston is offline  
Reply With Quote
Old 02-Nov-09, 03:07pm   #3
larrisajones
eh
 
larrisajones's Avatar
 
Member Since: Jun 2008

MemberID: 167611
Location: still here
Posts: 4,067
Nutt's been making controversial statements for ages - this was probably the straw that broke the camel’s back so to speak.
larrisajones is offline  
Reply With Quote
Old 02-Nov-09, 03:39pm   #4
Ruthykins
Life of the Search Party!
 
Ruthykins's Avatar
 
Member Since: Sep 2006

MemberID: 98390
Location: Moo Moo Bees
Posts: 5,840
the world (especially Australia) needs more Prof. Nutts!
__________________
flickr
Quote:
Originally Posted by Junglejunkie
Fuck i love you ITM. Youre like an abusive spouse that just bought me flowers for no reason.
Ruthykins is online now Send a message via MSN to Ruthykins   Reply With Quote
Old 02-Nov-09, 03:54pm   #5
thetron
mmmMMMMMmmmmm
 
thetron's Avatar
 
Member Since: Apr 2007

MemberID: 123455
Location: your dad.
Posts: 706
i like nutts.
thetron is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 02-Nov-09, 04:18pm   #6
Spicy
Unregistered User
 
Member Since: Dec 2007

MemberID: 150975
Location: Vag, HU
Posts: 5,170
what the?!

i thought actual scientific results were against what he and his friends claim. this is very interesting.
__________________
x - o +

music is the product of the highest human intelligence, and of the best senses, the listening senses and of imagination and intuition -- karlheinz stockhausen
Spicy is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 02-Nov-09, 04:29pm   #7
TrainsPillsBreaks
Registered User
 
Member Since: Apr 2009

MemberID: 194116
Location: WA, AU
Posts: 247
Quote:
Originally Posted by larrisajones
Nutt's been making controversial statements for ages

Cannabis being exceedingly less dangerous than alcohol and tobacco is an uncontroversial statement.
TrainsPillsBreaks is offline  
Reply With Quote
Old 02-Nov-09, 04:30pm   #8
dbb618
Mortal Avatar
 
dbb618's Avatar
 
Member Since: May 2006

MemberID: 89387
Location: Bubble Metropolis
Posts: 9,129
yes, but it is politically controversial.

The war on Some drugs continues unabated.
__________________
http://www.last.fm/user/dbbrx8/tracks

http://twitter.com/derekbradley

Quote:
Originally Posted by B_e_de
ur fkn drubnk
its the drunjunation of the future
dbb618 is online now   Reply With Quote
Old 02-Nov-09, 06:53pm   #9
YossarianIsSane
Registered User
 
YossarianIsSane's Avatar
 
Member Since: Nov 2005

MemberID: 75953
Location: WA, AU
Posts: 505
Quote:
Originally Posted by Spicy
what the?!

i thought actual scientific results were against what he and his friends claim. this is very interesting.

Be aware that he is talking not about individual doses or anything like that. That advisory council takes into account use trends, long term health costs and costs to the community as well.
YossarianIsSane is offline  
Reply With Quote
Old 02-Nov-09, 07:11pm   #10
THEHEATH
Registered User
 
THEHEATH's Avatar
 
Member Since: Jan 2003

MemberID: 17776
Location: My dirty, filthy, scummy flat?
Posts: 13,066
Every long term user I have ever known in NQR in the head. FACT.
__________________
Quote:
Originally Posted by magictorch
I am epileptic, so making fun of other people with epilepsy isn't making fun of people less fortunate.

Also, despite my epilepsy, I daresay I'm more fortunate than you, you condescending prick.
THEHEATH is offline Send a message via MSN to THEHEATH  
Reply With Quote
Old 02-Nov-09, 09:17pm   #11
big eddie
#wanker_club
 
big eddie's Avatar
 
Member Since: Jan 2003

MemberID: 18166
Location: the top
Posts: 25,048
I know plenty of people who a NQR in the head and I'm fairly sure they don't do drugs.
__________________
Quote:
Originally Posted by drater
I gave it another shot over the weekend. Once I got to halfway, I actually quite enjoyed the taste
big eddie is offline  
Reply With Quote
Old 02-Nov-09, 09:24pm   #12
toilet trained
Mr thunderbox
 
toilet trained's Avatar
 
Member Since: Jun 2002

MemberID: 10564
Location: on the potty
Posts: 3,693
Look basically he was saying that the danger of mary jane was adequately taken into consideration when it was declassified to a class C drug.

the govt decided to reclassify it as a class B drug, against the councils findings, purely out of percieved political gain (the torys were basically using it as a wedge issue)

all that is fine and good (not that i agree with the reclassification) BUT

then he was sacked for maintaining the opinion of the drug councils findings, and not toeing the governments line. it really is a complete mess. essentially the government is saying to its own advisers its fine to have a different opinion to the government, but you are not allowed to voice that opinion or really have any free speech in the matter at all, despite being advisers specifically set up to voice their scientific opinion on drug matters.

crazy.
__________________
hang on a minute, im on the potty doing poo





http://soundcloud.com/moth-hunter
toilet trained is offline  
Reply With Quote
Old 02-Nov-09, 09:48pm   #13
Dubz
Registered User
 
Dubz's Avatar
 
Member Since: Oct 2007

MemberID: 146504
Location: NSW, AU
Posts: 3,127
It's typical of a government that has completely lost it's way that it brings on experts and tells them that they want "the truth" and will follow their scientific findings....and then fire the experts when they dont come up with the results the MPs want.

I fucking hate Labour with the passion of a thousands suns. Sadly the conservatives are bizarrely turning into Labour.

MPs now no longer have any experience of real life.
__________________
Quote:
Originally Posted by Elliot G
"Dubz speaketh wisely"
Dubz is offline  
Reply With Quote
Old 03-Nov-09, 02:44pm   #14
ianwil1976
got cat?
 
ianwil1976's Avatar
 
Member Since: Oct 2004

MemberID: 49736
Posts: 22,772
Quote:
Originally Posted by THEHEATH
Every long term user I have ever known in NQR in the head. FACT.

I bet they just smoke sticky.
__________________
Facebook

"Silence! Find me churches! I feel a burning coming on, a terrible need to piss in a christening font..."
-- Spider Jerusalem, Transmetropolitan
ianwil1976 is online now   Reply With Quote
Old 03-Nov-09, 03:13pm   #15
twistedbydesign
grokkin it over
 
twistedbydesign's Avatar
 
Member Since: Mar 2004

MemberID: 37436
Location: Junkion
Posts: 14,876
Give it up for logic in power.
__________________
everything has already been pre-empted. And that allows people to be so cynical when something actually does happen, because they think they foresaw it - Kode9
A consistent thinker is a thoughtless person
he conforms to a pattern
repeats phrases
thinks in a groove
.


twistedbydesign is offline Send a message via MSN to twistedbydesign  
Reply With Quote
Old 03-Nov-09, 03:37pm   #16
CheelWinston
Chalkface
 
CheelWinston's Avatar
 
Member Since: May 2001

MemberID: 1134
Location: Cellz
Posts: 7,151
Quote:
Originally Posted by big eddie
I know plenty of people who a NQR in the head and I'm fairly sure they don't do drugs.

Not to mention people who sink a dozen schooners every day of the week.
__________________
cheel (till the next episode)

"Don't playa hate, calculate!"
"Don't playa hate, navigate!"
"Don't playa hate, amputate!"
"Don't playa hate, self-mutilate!"
"Don't playa hate, masticate!"
CheelWinston is offline  
Reply With Quote
Old 03-Nov-09, 08:31pm   #17
ianwil1976
got cat?
 
ianwil1976's Avatar
 
Member Since: Oct 2004

MemberID: 49736
Posts: 22,772
It's time like this that I really wish Bill Hicks hadn't departed the planet so fucking soon.
__________________
Facebook

"Silence! Find me churches! I feel a burning coming on, a terrible need to piss in a christening font..."
-- Spider Jerusalem, Transmetropolitan
ianwil1976 is online now   Reply With Quote
Old 03-Nov-09, 08:46pm   #18
JDxx
Audio Interspace Podcast
 
JDxx's Avatar
 
Member Since: Dec 2007

MemberID: 150833
Location: Earth.......I think
Posts: 154
Agreed. Bill Hicks, George Carlin & the likes, but yer, go the Nutt's 'ter!!!! Good on ya for fighting the good fight.
__________________
Please join Audio Interspace on iTunes & Face Book if you would like your EDM mixes/material to get that extra boost & further exposure via iTunes or direct download on the site.






RSS Feed on the site
JDxx is offline  
Reply With Quote
Old 03-Nov-09, 09:05pm   #19
Geezah
D'Oh
 
Geezah's Avatar
 
Member Since: Sep 2003

MemberID: 27476
Location: Evergrr.....mmn.....beer!
Posts: 5,809
The War is over. The Drugs won. I mean, Big Pharma already makes most of the shit legally, all you need to do is contract the Big C or the Big A or claim you is being chased by a Big Black Dog and you is gonna get on it anyways. Or fake a sleeping disorder, anxiety, obsessive compulsive disorder, or pretend you can not concentrate to the point of annoyance, and ya know, you wil get on it.

Pollies and the Stupids still make this shit an issue, when prohibition is the number one cause for people dying on illicit substances. Its a fucking waste of tax-payers money incarcerating and prosecuting users, it is a waste of time, it is the definition of insanity being tough on drugs. Governments are so fucking stupid. They could legalise and regulate recreational drugs, it would take them about 6 months, and then all the lies about saying they will fix shit will become truths. It is mind-bogglingly exasperating that we are still having this argument in 2009.

Humans couldn`t organise to be intelligent in a Mathematorium.
__________________
Quote:
Homer: Bad bees! Get away from my sugar! Ow! OW!! Oh, they're defending themselves somehow!
Geezah is offline  
Reply With Quote
Old 03-Nov-09, 10:25pm   #20
ianwil1976
got cat?
 
ianwil1976's Avatar
 
Member Since: Oct 2004

MemberID: 49736
Posts: 22,772
Quote:
Originally Posted by JDxx
Agreed. Bill Hicks, George Carlin & the likes, but yer, go the Nutt's 'ter!!!! Good on ya for fighting the good fight.

Carlin died at 71, a pretty good innings. Hicks was 32

Geezah, well said.
__________________
Facebook

"Silence! Find me churches! I feel a burning coming on, a terrible need to piss in a christening font..."
-- Spider Jerusalem, Transmetropolitan
ianwil1976 is online now   Reply With Quote
Old 03-Nov-09, 10:34pm   #21
THEHEATH
Registered User
 
THEHEATH's Avatar
 
Member Since: Jan 2003

MemberID: 17776
Location: My dirty, filthy, scummy flat?
Posts: 13,066
Quote:
Originally Posted by big eddie
I know plenty of people who a NQR in the head and I'm fairly sure they don't do drugs.
Yes but these people were normal before.
__________________
Quote:
Originally Posted by magictorch
I am epileptic, so making fun of other people with epilepsy isn't making fun of people less fortunate.

Also, despite my epilepsy, I daresay I'm more fortunate than you, you condescending prick.
THEHEATH is offline Send a message via MSN to THEHEATH  
Reply With Quote
Old 03-Nov-09, 10:49pm   #22
hatzornotahat
is not an alias
 
hatzornotahat's Avatar
 
Member Since: Feb 2009

MemberID: 190661
Location: QLD, AU
Posts: 2,248
It seems to me that we are simply undergoing an extended period of (drug) Prohibition, including all its tragic failings. It's all too telling that the mistakes of the past are to be repeated. Perhaps when a more informed and enlightened generation enters the parliamentary system the issue will be dealt with definitively. Then again, ignorance breeds ignorance especially in political circumstances, so we could be stuck this way for a long time to come.
__________________
I'm pregnant with a baby elephant, the trunk is already out.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Dbauch
if someone spends all their days posting on an internet music site about crap, then they have no people skills or real friends and are unemployed with no prospects
hatzornotahat is offline  
Reply With Quote
Old 04-Nov-09, 01:30am   #23
Stavros
.exe
 
Member Since: Dec 2002

MemberID: 17597
Location: Lunch box of choice
Posts: 959
Quote:
Originally Posted by THEHEATH
Yes but these people were normal before.

Is there a device that measures a standard normal measure that you can point me to? Or is it a relative, subjective and biased opinion?
How do you explain people who consume cannabis that are QR in the head?
Stavros is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 04-Nov-09, 11:29am   #24
ianwil1976
got cat?
 
ianwil1976's Avatar
 
Member Since: Oct 2004

MemberID: 49736
Posts: 22,772
Of course, sillyhead, it's called the kneejerk-o-meter.
__________________
Facebook

"Silence! Find me churches! I feel a burning coming on, a terrible need to piss in a christening font..."
-- Spider Jerusalem, Transmetropolitan
ianwil1976 is online now   Reply With Quote
Old 04-Nov-09, 07:29pm   #25
tone_loc
Registered User
 
Member Since: Sep 2007

MemberID: 142585
Location: NSW, AU
Posts: 119
Quote:
extract from a letter written by the MP responsible for the sacking (Alan Johnson):

He was asked to go because he cannot be both a government adviser and a campaigner against government policy. This principle is well understood and long established.

As for his comments about horse riding being more dangerous than ecstasy, which you quote with such reverence, it is of course a political rather than a scientific point. There are not many kids in my constituency in danger of falling off a horse – there are thousands at risk of being sucked into a world of hopeless despair through drug addiction.

it seems it is a well understood and long established principle that one cannot be a government adviser and also advise the government that it is wrong.

also love his dismissal of the statistical fact that horse riding is more dangerous than ecstasy; "a political rather than a scientific point."
tone_loc is offline  
Reply With Quote
Old 04-Nov-09, 07:38pm   #26
Carte Blanche
SHIFT_ your feet
 
Carte Blanche's Avatar
 
Member Since: Jul 2004

MemberID: 42910
Location: feeling love
Posts: 6,049
Give Nick Clegg a go imo.

__________________
Lagom är bäst.

Lush. Groovy. Melodic.

.: House Sessions 006: Helsinki :.

En existens utan progbombar är inte alls en existens.
Carte Blanche is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 04-Nov-09, 09:13pm   #27
THEHEATH
Registered User
 
THEHEATH's Avatar
 
Member Since: Jan 2003

MemberID: 17776
Location: My dirty, filthy, scummy flat?
Posts: 13,066
Quote:
Originally Posted by Stavros
Is there a device that measures a standard normal measure that you can point me to? Or is it a relative, subjective and biased opinion?
How do you explain people who consume cannabis that are QR in the head?
No device, they are observations, but it's fairly simple. You take a persons ability to function in society/socially before becoming a chronic user, then compare that to their ability to do it after chronic use. You then take your observations over several groups of people and draw your conclusion.

Voila, what do you know, every chronic user I know is fucked in the head. Show me a drug that is used heavily that doesn't have a long term negative affect on people?

Hey I'm not anti-weed. I've done it, each to their own. I just like to add my 2 cents because whenever the question of legalization gets brought up it seems to become a bit of a love in.
__________________
Quote:
Originally Posted by magictorch
I am epileptic, so making fun of other people with epilepsy isn't making fun of people less fortunate.

Also, despite my epilepsy, I daresay I'm more fortunate than you, you condescending prick.
THEHEATH is offline Send a message via MSN to THEHEATH  
Reply With Quote
Old 04-Nov-09, 09:32pm   #28
big eddie
#wanker_club
 
big eddie's Avatar
 
Member Since: Jan 2003

MemberID: 18166
Location: the top
Posts: 25,048
Question of separating the mental health issue from the law and order one imo.
__________________
Quote:
Originally Posted by drater
I gave it another shot over the weekend. Once I got to halfway, I actually quite enjoyed the taste
big eddie is offline  
Reply With Quote
Old 04-Nov-09, 10:18pm   #29
toilet trained
Mr thunderbox
 
toilet trained's Avatar
 
Member Since: Jun 2002

MemberID: 10564
Location: on the potty
Posts: 3,693
Quote:
Originally Posted by THEHEATH
No device, they are observations, but it's fairly simple. You take a persons ability to function in society/socially before becoming a chronic user, then compare that to their ability to do it after chronic use. You then take your observations over several groups of people and draw your conclusion.

Voila, what do you know, every chronic user I know is fucked in the head. Show me a drug that is used heavily that doesn't have a long term negative affect on people?

Hey I'm not anti-weed. I've done it, each to their own. I just like to add my 2 cents because whenever the question of legalization gets brought up it seems to become a bit of a love in.


i agree with you in the main (although i know a few chronic smokers, none of who are wonky in the head, but when i was at school a few of the fellow kids ended up in psych ward for good on the stuff) but again, it was the councils thoughts that the dangers were adequately taken into consideration when it was a class C drug.

Also, the council took into account the other social problems from 'waging war on users' i.e the long term consequences of giving users criminal convictions and the evidence that reclassification would not (and indeed has not) reduced usage one iota.

The reason the issue flared up was the government was hearing stories of 'super weed' hydro stuff that was apparently knocking alot of people up. but the statistics on schizophrenia said otherwise, there was no increase in schizophrenia or other serious mental illness attributed to weed use.

in actual fact the biggest problem with weed in the UK (apparently) is that its actually very very poor quality. and most stuff sold as 'soap bar' (low grade resin) has all sorts of crap in it that isn't weed, and poses far more serious health concerns, a problem which would obviously be overcome if weed was de-criminalized and regulated...clearly no point telling the government that though
__________________
hang on a minute, im on the potty doing poo





http://soundcloud.com/moth-hunter
toilet trained is offline  
Reply With Quote
Old 06-Nov-09, 07:57am   #30
ticketsplease
Frankee More
 
ticketsplease's Avatar
 
Member Since: Sep 2002

MemberID: 13421
Location: NSW, AU
Posts: 1,018
Quote:
Originally Posted by THEHEATH

Voila, what do you know, every chronic user I know is fucked in the head. Show me a drug that is used heavily that doesn't have a long term negative affect on people?

Hey I'm not anti-weed. I've done it, each to their own. I just like to add my 2 cents because whenever the question of legalization gets brought up it seems to become a bit of a love in.

More Nutt here.
http://www.newscientist.com/article/...-on-drugs.html
ticketsplease is offline  
Reply With Quote
Old 06-Nov-09, 08:05am   #31
ticketsplease
Frankee More
 
ticketsplease's Avatar
 
Member Since: Sep 2002

MemberID: 13421
Location: NSW, AU
Posts: 1,018
'No one doubts that heavy users of marijuana are risking trouble with their mental health. What I have simply pointed out is that we need a consistent policy, recognising that heavy users of alcohol and tobacco are more numerous and are causing themselves – and others – even more trouble through their indulgence.'

Nutt - so you know its true.
ticketsplease is offline  
Reply With Quote
Old 09-Nov-09, 07:49am   #32
NanouK
safe innit
 
NanouK's Avatar
 
Member Since: Oct 2002

MemberID: 15419
Location: London
Posts: 1,013
Quote:
Originally Posted by THEHEATH
Every long term user I have ever known in NQR in the head. OPINION.

fixed
__________________
"Anyone who lives within their means, suffers from a serious lack of imagaination" .... Oscar Wilde
NanouK is offline  
Reply With Quote
Old 10-Nov-09, 07:22pm   #33
DaveHarvey
Unregistered Abuser
 
DaveHarvey's Avatar
 
Member Since: Jan 2008

MemberID: 154086
Location: BNE
Posts: 17
Quote:
Originally Posted by Carte Blanche
Give Nick Clegg a go imo.


Not a bad idea.

http://drevanharrismp.wordpress.com/...or-david-nutt/
DaveHarvey is offline  
Reply With Quote
Old 12-Nov-09, 04:26pm   #34
ezz_
bearded ladeh
 
ezz_'s Avatar
 
Member Since: Jan 2002

MemberID: 6414
Location: beards, beards, beards
Posts: 1,630
http://www.thesun.co.uk/sol/homepage...n-3-years.html

this looks interesting. healthy, synthetic alcohol? yes fucking please.

i LOVE the sensationalist reporting too
__________________
your face has fallen sad now
for you know that the time is nigh
when i must remove your wings
and you must try to fly



i think of you in motion and just how close you are getting, and how every little thing anticipates you...
ezz_ is online now Send a message via MSN to ezz_  
Reply With Quote
Reply


Thread Tools Search this Thread
Search this Thread:

Advanced Search

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

vB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
Forum Jump


All times are GMT +10. The time now is 09:52am.