Critics slam Irvine Welsh's Ecstasy movie

Image for Critics slam Irvine Welsh's Ecstasy movie

Earlier this year, we keenly reported that the Irvine Welsh book Ecstasy: Three Tales of Chemical Romance had been given the silver screen treatment, with the trailer showing promising signs of a rollicking trip through the Edinburgh club scene of the ‘90s. The film version of Irvine Welsh’s Ecstasy also boasts a cameo appearance from one John Digweed (he obviously enjoyed his Groove moment) and a soundtrack that includes Orbital, Primal Scream, Paul Oakenfold and Tiesto. We sincerely hoped it would join the ‘clubbing movie’ Hall Of Fame.

The film – which was released in the UK in 2011 – is now in limited release in cinemas across Australia, but critics have not been kind to the finished product. Over at Rotten Tomatoes, Ecstasy is sitting at a dismal 6% on the critics’ ‘Tomatometer’. “A crass and shallow exploration of a potentially interesting topic, which makes for one downer of a cinematic trip,” wrote Filmink.

In the words of Time Out London’s reviewer: “It gets itself in a real thematic tangle, one-minute espousing the liberating potency of ‘disco biscuits’ and a kickin’ DJ set, then later insisting that real life and real emotions only begin once illicit substances are out of the equation. Like so many drug movies it starts out down-with-the-kids but ends up preaching.”

And on and on the acerbic reviews go. But hey, maybe they’re all wrong! Have you managed to catch it on one of its very-occasional screenings? Or will you be warily waiting for DVD? Let us know in the comments section below.

Social

Comments

www.inthemix.com.au arrow left
304982
Onslaught

Onslaught said on the 8th May, 2012

Yep, because the movie is simply..... boring and lifeless.

Can't believe there is still an audience for this type of movie:

Club Scene - Drug Scene - Club Scene - Kristin fkn Kruek?!

sillyclimber

sillyclimber said on the 8th May, 2012

IMDB gives it 3.6. BLAH!

http://www.imdb.com/title/tt1552221/

kone

kone said on the 8th May, 2012

not too much of a story behind clubbing and drugs generally...when it goes well, go out dance for many hours feel good. boring to hear about.

when its bad, people start out ok then stop going out for a good time, just do the drugs instead and end up feeling bad, possibly leading to addiction. depressing and predictable

special ed

special ed said on the 8th May, 2012

lets be clear here. Irvine Welsh wrote a brilliant book. Rob Heyden directed a pile of shit movie adaptation(from all reports)

mlirosi

mlirosi said on the 8th May, 2012

wont be up there with the all time greats like dj girl

freo

freo said on the 8th May, 2012

Whoa - Some of you are actually talking about the wrong movie!
@sillyclimber, that IMDB link and score of 3.6 is a totally different movie.
You are actually looking for http://www.imdb.com/title/tt1809287/ - "Irvine Welsh's Ecstasy" which has a score of 5.0 *but only 169 votes so far.
As for rotten tomatoes, critics don't like movies like this. The audience vote is 56%...
Rottentomatoes has a score of 98% for a doco about a sushi restaurant... http://www.rottentomatoes.com/m/jiro_dreams_of_sushi

SirDrBenny

SirDrBenny said on the 8th May, 2012

i wonder if anyone else has picked up the fact they spelt IW's name wrong in the OFFICIAL TRAILER... :stroke:

oops.

JackT

JackT said on the 8th May, 2012

I don't think DJ Girl was ever released. I fear we may have destroyed it.

midian

midian said on the 8th May, 2012

This movie was much better when it was called TomTom's

MikePoker

MikePoker said on the 8th May, 2012

I loved the film. It is a different story from Trainspotting. All older critics who compared it to Trainspotting lost the plot. Misunderstood by so many, Ecstasy has been dogged by unfair comparisons to Trainspotting. At heart, it's a warm-the-cockles tale of love with an overarching comic tone and a far less fatalistic - and depressing -- message than its progenitor; the Scottish setting and narcotics-related narrative are really where the similarities end. Complete with scenes that make us wince and squirm, as well as those that make us smile and smirk, Ecstasy is a commendable debut from a Canadian director who has great affection for his Scottish subject matter

Twizard

Twizard said on the 9th May, 2012

I'd give this a watch.

Loving the Irvine Welsh quote: "If someone doesn't like this film they are a cunt."

riio

riio said on the 9th May, 2012

Saw this In London a few weeks ago, unfortunately misses the mark in so many aspects, Especially in the 'romance' aspect of the storyline with the main character sprouting some very cheesy lines......

deck

deck said on the 9th May, 2012

Quote: riio "with the main character snorting some lines......"

I bet he did.

shaway

shaway said on the 9th May, 2012

I'm really not surprised

macc4

macc4 said on the 9th May, 2012

I thought this was going to be a shit article, but then I read it and I think it turned out ok

Rogan Josh

Rogan Josh said on the 11th May, 2012

What Onslaught said up there ^

Do people still want to watch these "ravers getting loved-up at the Haienda when the pills were good" type movies?
Zzz...