Australian professor claims ecstasy 'safer than booze binges'

www.inthemix.com.au
  • 49
  • 0
  • 6109

Professor Jake Najman, a leading Australian drugs expert, has said ecstasy is ‘cheaper, safer’ and a ‘lesser evil’ than alcohol following the publication of research showing young people are switching from alcopops following the new Government tax.

Ecstasy is “relatively benign if taken in small quantities,” the director of Queensland’s Alcohol and Drug Research Center told the Brisbane Times. “When young people switch from a substantial amount of alcohol to a small amount of ecstasy… I don’t think that’s a bad trade at all. It is not likely that one pill on a Saturday night poses the same dangers as frequent binge drinking,” he added.

The Professor’s comments coincided with a report in the Guardian on Britain’s escalating drinking culture which revealed that 15,000 people die from alcohol related conditions a year with additional health problems increasingly common. Liver expert Professor Roger Williams, who treated now dead soccer star George Best, warned that drinking even slightly over the official limits of 21 units for men and 14 units for women a week regularly poses significant health threats and reeled off a long list of horrific side effects.

“I see a lot of pancreatitis… a hideous, hideous illness,” the Professor noted. “Then there is atrophy of the brain and the early onset of dementia. Alcohol raises blood pressure. There is damage to the peripheral nerves of the legs and arms – people get foot drop, where they can’t pick their feet up properly,” he warned.

Nobody has hearted this, be the first Be the first!

Comments

www.inthemix.com.au arrow left
Comment Added
i a i n g

i a i n g said on the 12th Sep, 2008

yes but of all th ecstacy users in australia, i would imagine its a very very small percentage that have just ONE pill in a night.

sonicc

sonicc said on the 12th Sep, 2008

Safer??? I wanna live on the edge, screw it im switching to heroin.

the elektro kitten

the elektro kitten said on the 12th Sep, 2008

Thank god not everyone is sucked into the mainstream government views. I'm glad someone can look at tax benefits the government receives, aside from their research. Bravo

BaileyLSD

BaileyLSD said on the 12th Sep, 2008

Wonder what the damage on binge drinking plus x is?

partydavo

partydavo said on the 12th Sep, 2008

Everything in MODERATION is fine! As soon as you abuse anything.. you will cause harm to yourself! Alcohol and Cigarettes lead to more premature disease and death than any other recreational substances! Plus, a club full of happy go lucky punters pillin

fuze_crew

fuze_crew said on the 12th Sep, 2008

TAKE LOOT HOLLAND . MAYBE WE SHOULD BE LOOKING AT THEY ARE DOING AND THE UK.

dj joey

dj joey said on the 12th Sep, 2008

alchie makes me wanna bash people..Eeee makes me wanna hug and love people..cmon government..just legalise the stuff, sell it in petrol stations, and claim a tax on it..then itll be all good for youse!

mcdoofus

mcdoofus said on the 12th Sep, 2008

i a i n g - I think if people could find pills that were a decent dose of guaranteed clean MDMA then a lot more would only take one in a night. And I'd be willing to bet that those who go overboard on ecstasy are probably going overboard on a lot of other

poonige

poonige said on the 12th Sep, 2008

i a i n g, Im sure if pills were pure MDMA and were manufactured with controls on the quantity and quality of MDMA I am sure 1 to 2 pills would be sufficiant for a night. Most only take large quantities cause pills these days mostly have low quantities of

SA_spec

SA_spec said on the 12th Sep, 2008

haha dj joey should run the country (provided he has a responisble controlled supply of x). someone that overdoes x is far less dangerous than someone that overdoes alcohol, take it from fist hand experience. Most x users stop when theyve had enough, i us

Fewsion

Fewsion said on the 12th Sep, 2008

another ecstasy good alcohol bad news report? i'm shocked.

Captain Dance Floor

Captain Dance Floor said on the 12th Sep, 2008

I have been saying this for years. The war on drugs is a pathetic attempt at medievil style control. The world would be a much better place and less people would die/be in jail for crime or be affected by crime if drugs were legalised. And the government

Cobbles

Cobbles said on the 12th Sep, 2008

aha eky from a petrol station, that'l be the day...

dimeuleh

dimeuleh said on the 12th Sep, 2008

I actually would like to see the comparison in alcohol related deaths compared to ecstasy .. just ecstasy not mixed! Maybe that would actually shine some light to how "dangerous" and "harmful" such a illegal drug is in comparison to the so called "legal"

AVB_No_1

AVB_No_1 said on the 12th Sep, 2008

Watch, in 10 years Googs will be legal and the goverment will start putting their tax on pills lol. (They will make a killing)

humdingaling

humdingaling said on the 12th Sep, 2008

i wonder who funds theses so called reports

Shatter

Shatter said on the 12th Sep, 2008

I've never met a person who has taken X in moderation... ever. And I know a lot of people on the scene. Every newcomer will hit that shit up every weekend and inevitably burn out and get depression after 6 months of use. And, no, I'm not claiming binge dr

Dyslexic JD

Dyslexic JD said on the 12th Sep, 2008

Green lighting x?? I wonder what the AMA would say?

Garthyboy

Garthyboy said on the 12th Sep, 2008

I have to agree with the instant effects of X abuse vs alcohol abuse Much rather have a munted guy on X being a tool around me than an agro boozed up bloke looking for a fight.

Spekman

Spekman said on the 12th Sep, 2008

the issue is they are speaking of clean ecstacy, not the rubbish a lot of pills have in them these days.. sure you can get clean, but a lot aren't... and its the stuff that isn't X which is really bad for you.. if the government legalised and regulated

mcdoofus

mcdoofus said on the 12th Sep, 2008

Shatter - I dunno who you're hanging out with but not everyone burns themselves out in 6 months. Do you know anyone with some self-control? In my experience, about half the people that use ecstasy do it the way you descibed, hitting it up every weekend un

its_mish

its_mish said on the 12th Sep, 2008

you silly, naive, ignorant people who use drugs, its the devil, think of the mothers at home crying and praying and the families you destroy by using this crap and dealing. Get a life and get off the drugs especially you professor Jake Najman. I'm at mos

partydavo

partydavo said on the 12th Sep, 2008

Our bodies are equipped with a biochemical factory that produces chemicals and hormones to make us feel and act a certain way.. taking E.. releases seratonin and adrenaline.. natural chems that already exist in your body! Alcohol - is a poison! The effec

Spekman

Spekman said on the 12th Sep, 2008

its_mish, its more dangerous to drive a car then take pills... get off your high horse...

dimeuleh

dimeuleh said on the 12th Sep, 2008

its_mish . your a tool. -end

mcdoofus

mcdoofus said on the 12th Sep, 2008

its mish - Ever had a drink in your life? Think of all the people who have had their lives ruined by alcohol! Get off your high horse.

SA_spec

SA_spec said on the 12th Sep, 2008

its_mish, thats hilarious, i lost t when i read ur comment, i cant believe ur serious and if you are then i still applaud you for playin tha 'tool of the devil' card, bah, anyways its fri, need ta get me some fuuuuurked urp!!

johno_ast

johno_ast said on the 12th Sep, 2008

it would be great if you only needed 1 pill a night..... gone are the days of decent pills..... anyone remember orange butterflys and red rolexs and even yellow doves

trancejunkii

trancejunkii said on the 12th Sep, 2008

normal people just don't understand this.... they need to be educated as this is a very well known fact already from within the dance community.... u definitely are likely to do more long term damage from binge drinking than from occasionally dropping an

macky

macky said on the 12th Sep, 2008

well theyve convince me! haha

Kid A

Kid A said on the 12th Sep, 2008

It's wrong to say that everything in moderation is fine.. it's simply not true. And the argument that certain drugs are better than others because they aren't foreign from what is already chemically contained in our brains doesn't stand up. Chemical imbal

macky

macky said on the 12th Sep, 2008

they have AAA meetings for alcohol abusers, they have rehab centres for constant drug users. U will most likely find that more ppl are attending AAA meetings rather than joining a rehab clinic. Doing X, u r actually in a more controlled state than alcoho

Suga05

Suga05 said on the 12th Sep, 2008

Considering Australia is one of the world's fattest countries and alcohol makes you gain weight then I think ths would be a good way of solving both binge drinking and weight problems :-P haha

I Film Shit

I Film Shit said on the 13th Sep, 2008

Good work Jake Najman you idiot. Encourage people to take more drugs. Ever heard of selective listening? what uve said is SMALL AMOUNTS of ecstasy is ok and alcohol is bad. BUT any drug user who reads this is ONLY going to see DRUGS ARE SAFER THAN ACOHOL.

amria_101

amria_101 said on the 13th Sep, 2008

Little does everyone know that some US doctor's tried to prescribe ectasy back in the 1970s for counselling methods. But I must agree burn out and depression after 6 months of use is a definate, the "after" far outweighs the "on" after a while, which lead

bobshled

bobshled said on the 13th Sep, 2008

Man, its all about where is came from. Most of th time it could come from anywhere, and have any additives in it. LEGALISE. Haha as if though.

Advice Dog

Advice Dog said on the 13th Sep, 2008

DON'T EAT PILLS SHELVE THEM INSTEAD

Rstavv

Rstavv said on the 13th Sep, 2008

woohoo score one for the bad guys aaahahaha

partydavo

partydavo said on the 13th Sep, 2008

Macky is right - alcohol is a depressant - E is a stimulant. When you're influenced by a stimulant you are far more in control and aware of your surrounding environment. Plus being the precursor for the neurotransmitter Seratonin; its happy days all round

partydavo

partydavo said on the 13th Sep, 2008

Oh and its_mish - you'll note that the music 'industry' would be a very boring place if it weren't for the influence of drugs through its evolution..

rotisserie

rotisserie said on the 13th Sep, 2008

party davo taking x is still taking something thats not 'naturally' in your body, its still affecting u in the long term, every time u take ecstasy, it quickly releases the serotonin u have, so u feel really happy for a short time - then it slowly repleni

stu_jacks88

stu_jacks88 said on the 14th Sep, 2008

More and more we see professionals coming out with comments and reports like this. Doctors from my university (which will remain anonymous) have discussed with me and others many a time about the legalisation and control of specific party drugs for the pu

SlicyDicer

SlicyDicer said on the 14th Sep, 2008

Drinking in moderation isn't fun

mcdoofus

mcdoofus said on the 14th Sep, 2008

rotisserie - Have you got a link showing that on average your maximum serotonin supplies are lower after using ecstasy? Didn't think so.

UntilMonday

UntilMonday said on the 14th Sep, 2008

who has JUST one pill tho? I say both drink and drop... two negatives equal a positive right? that's wat i learnt in high school anyway!

katie90

katie90 said on the 14th Sep, 2008

if e's were legal, and government made. atleast they cud controll wats in it. and u wud no wat ur gettin and its not sumn made in someones back yard full of messed up stuff thats wat hurts u.. PLUS... 4 litres of alcohol compared to a tiny pill, i think u

Gspot

Gspot said on the 15th Sep, 2008

I've been partying for 10yrs and taking e's for 10yrs now. But it really takes a few more yrs of maturity before you realise what your body can handle and the individual effects it has on your body. We all know alcohol and drugs affect people differently